Fans preferred these 10 movie adaptations over the original books


Not so long ago, a survey was conducted by SuperSummary which sought to reach consensus on the perception of fans of films adapted into films. From this survey, it was found that a number of movie franchises were preferred over source material, regardless of the critical opinion of sites like Rotten Tomatoes. To be fair, the first entries on this list lean towards books rather than movies.

RELATED: 10 Must-See ‘Rotten’ Movies About Rotten Tomatoes

However, since the percentage of people who chose the movies was quite large, we compiled 10 movies and franchises that were able to fend for themselves from this survey. In fact, the majority of them far surpass books in popularity, so read on and see if you feel the same way.

ten Charlotte’s canvas

A story about the relationship between Charlotte the Spider and Wilbur the Pig, this film is about the power of friendship despite the characters being two very different species. With a featured cast with Julia Roberts and Dakota Fanning, Charlotte’s canvas does pretty big at the box office.

While a good number of viewers preferred the book over the movie, the important part who liked the screen adaptation better did so for good reason, as the chemistry between the actors is worth mentioning.

9 Harry Potter Series

Everyone knows the boy sorcerer whose popularity dominated the end of the previous century and most of the present century. Harry potter was always going to have a bigger fan base for the books, but a surprising number of people chose the movies over that.

This was most likely because the current generation was not born or just weren’t old enough to remember the hype when a new one Harry potter book would be published. It is also one of the Harry potter mediums that has remained immune to the number of retroactive changes made by JK Rowling.

8 The Twilight Saga

Twilight Breaking Dawn part 2 almost fixed the wrong end of the book

If the survey had been carried out a few years earlier, we have no doubt that The Twilight Saga would have been at the top of the list. Back when the movies were coming out, their popularity was so great that people tended to forget that the books came first.

And while the films have aged rather well, the ratio of fans preferring the book has increased slightly. However, there’s not much to separate the books and the movie fanbase, which means you’ll likely find a lot of people who preferred the screen adaptation.

7 The Hunger Games series

If it hadn’t been for the lack of sparkle Mockingjay movies, then we can be sure that more people would have voted for the screen adaptations rather than the books. Even today, the competition is neck and neck between the two, and we understand why.

RELATED: The Hunger Games: 10 Most Shameless Things Peeta Has Ever Done

After all, this series that put women’s empowerment at the forefront, like Katniss Everdeen’s role in a political uprising, where she fights and leads, has made her an extremely strong character. Not to mention the star power of actors like Jennifer Lawrence and Liam Hemsworth.

6 The Lord of the Rings Trilogy

This is where fan preference begins to shift unmistakably towards film versions, like The Lord of the RingsThe on-screen success saw his popularity stay the exact same for fans, even two decades later.

This is also due to the fact that the books have a very sinuous rhythm, which makes reading them a bit of a pain, especially for the current generation. The sheer quality of the films, however, ensures that viewers frequently take a trip to Middle-earth to watch Frodo’s journey to destroy the One Ring.

5 The brilliant

Films based on the works of Stephen King have become so famous that they have resulted in the novels losing popularity. The case in point is The brilliant, which continues to be successful after four decades. This should be attributed to director Stanley Kubrick, whose work was such that you don’t have to read the book to feel its spooky effects.

TThe director’s many changes – most of them for the better – led to the screen adaptation’s biggest success.

4 Notebook

Movies based on Nicholas Sparks’ books have fallen into disuse in recent years, but they were at their peak when Notebook has been freed. This film has become so iconic in romantic pop culture that it turned the main actors into instant superstars.

RELATED: 10 Movies Starring The Cast Of The Avengers You Didn’t Know

Plus, the film is easily the best screen adaptation of a book by Nicholas Sparks, lacking some of the more cheesy elements that later films would have. Most of the time, however, it was the chemistry between the actors that saw the film stay way ahead of the book.

3 Charlie and the chocolate factory

In what is another example of a book too old to remain as relevant as before, Charlie and the chocolate factoryThe film version of trumps the source material to be close to contemporary times in its release.

While Johnny Depp and Freddie Highmore remain well known to audiences, the film has become a classic. It also helps the special effects still hold, which led to the kids watching the movie for the first time and becoming instant fans.

2 Jurassic Park Series

Up to 68% of respondents voted in favor of the film version of jurassic park, with another large amount preferring both versions. It’s hard to argue against moviegoers because jurassic park is a cinematic wonder that will never go out of style.

There are some drastic differences between the book and the movie as well, and the latter is better in every way, from the character development to the awesome scenes. With Jurassic World resulting from this series, the books really have no chance of catching up with their popularity.

1 Forrest Gump

If you were to ask a group of people if they liked Forrest Gumpin the version of the book, almost everyone would be surprised at the existence of the novel. The film was so successful that 79% voted for the adaptation and only 5% opted for the book.

Tom Hanks has become synonymous with Forrest, and his masterful performance has gone beyond the characterization found in the pages of the book. At least in the case of Forrest Gump, it can be said without a shadow of a doubt that the film is the superior version of the story.

NEXT: Dare Me: 10 Books From Our Teens We Want From Movies / Shows

The Avengers: a quote from each member that goes against their personality

About the Author

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.