Adaptations can always be a hit or miss with the audience. Sometimes the adaptation skyrockets, exceeding audience expectations while embodying the identity of the source. Other times, he falters and lets the audience down, berating everything that made the source material so great. Of course, it all depends on the source.
For the most part, the adaptation is only for books, but the truth is, while the majority of adaptations are based on books, others are from different forms of media. Comics and video game adaptations can stray so far from their original sources that they end up being two separate projects.
ten Noah (2014)
By all accounts, Noah, the 2014 film based on the story of Noah and the Flood, is not very precise. To be sure, the adaptation borrows much more from the book of Enoch than from the familiar and recognizable scriptures of the Bible.
Yet the movie still tries its best to be a massive action-adventure flick with fallen angels, a vicious warlord, and big CGI fights when all that was recorded was Noah stepped onto the ark. and walked away with the animals and the family. No further conflict is necessary.
9 Jaws (1975)
Audiences will always remember the classic movie that scared them of water and the movie that put Stephen Speilberg on the map, Jaws. What they don’t seem to realize is that the novel the films are based on is drastically different from the film.
More deaths, bloodier descriptions of the shark appearing frequently, a scorching conflict between Hopper and Brody’s wife, and an anti-climate ending that lacks the massive explosion offered by the film make this one of the few times the movie was better than the book.
8 World War II (2013)
The sad truth about zombies is that they have been killed. Still, Second World War, written by Max Brooks, breathed new life into the genre, serving as an anthology of personal stories after a deadly zombie plague swept the world.
However, for some reason Hollywood chose to leave anthology style and personal accounts behind and made its 2013 adaptation of Brad Pitt surviving a zombie plague in search of a cure. Again, tropes prevail and not for the betterment of the story or film.
7 The Brilliant (1980)
For many horror fans, The brilliant is the greatest horror film ever made, serving as a deep dive into cabin fever and its psyche while having a supernatural feel. Yet it has been said that The brilliant is quite different from the book.
Yes, the horror and the main ideas are still there, but multiple ideas come out. The movie is more about the hotel owning someone than about Jack going crazy, there is more wrestling between Jack and one of the scariest hotels in cinema, a focus on Danny, less deaths and a finale. explosive.
6 The Hobbit (2012)
Pretty much every adaptation, book or whatever, will attempt to stretch the source material more than it should. The Hobbit, based on the three hundred and four page book, is a trilogy of films that really could have been two or even one.
Beyond the dramatically stretched storylines, the film adaptation adds some characters from the LOTR world like Legolas and Sauron while giving seven full pages to an almost three hour long film with The battle of the five armies. In short, it made things bloated and unnecessary.
5 Captain America: Civil War (2016)
As acclaimed as he is, Captain America: Civil War, does not follow source material well. It’s true, the concept is there; the feeling of heroes divided over a terrible incident and the world not knowing who to side with. Key details, however, were lost in the translation.
No event orchestration by Zemo, a battle against Bucky Barnes, Spider-Man’s identity remaining a secret, Cap not surrendering and then obtaining murdered, and Tony Stark reprising SHIELD are just a few details. While Civil war is a great movie, it and the comics are drastically different.
4 Catwoman (2004)
Selina Kyle is a tough guy. Batman’s enemy / lover, a master thief and a brilliant woman in her own right, Catwoman It would have been a hell of a movie to watch if it had been about Selina Kyle. Instead, it was Patience Phillips.
Ditching the old ways and opting for a new character who felt weak compared to the original Catwoman, the 2004 film felt like a mistaken departure from the now iconic character. That, along with the bizarre basketball scene, makes him a superhero dud.
3 Unleashed (2018)
Now at its base Carnage, the 2018 monster movie that followed The Rock taking on genetically mutated monsters, appears to follow the source material. Except for the fact that the movie tried to add a story to an arcade game that didn’t have a story.
The arcade game offers a very vague premise of mutated humanoids terrorizing a city, but never elaborates on that setup. The film adaptation attempted to mess around with rabies-inducing drugs that enhanced an animal’s physical attributes alongside a corporate plot.
2 Doom (2005)
Movies based on blockbuster video games hardly ever turn out according to audiences’ expectations, and at no point has this been more evident than the release of the 2005s. Loss, a film that took the phrase “loosely based on” to new heights of ridicule.
Rather than being a lone soldier battling the forces of Hell with a shotgun, Loss sees a group of Marines battling scientists who have been mutated by alien DNA. No Doomguy, weak attempts to connect to the games, and a bizarre history with the Rock make this an unrecognizable adaptation.
1 Resident Evil (2002)
The resident Evil The game franchise is, for the most part, a mainstay of the survival horror genre. Detailing an outbreak of mutated zombies, classic survivors like Jill Valentine, Leon Kennedy, Claire, and Chris Redfield rally against the living dead and challenging boss fights like Nemesis. At least that’s what games do.
The movies, less. While the concept of the living dead is there, the movies go more into the apocalypse than games ever did and ditch the sense of survival horror for all-out action. Additionally, the film series sidelines the protagonists of the games in favor of Alice, a brand new character who does not appear in the games.
NEXT: Best Adaptations Of Agatha Christie’s Work, According To Rotten Tomatoes
10 martial arts movies to watch if you love Shang-Chi
About the Author